Print this page

General Bipin Rawat’s threat of military option against China misplaced Featured

  28 August 2020
Rate this item
(0 votes)

‘Appear weak when you are strong, and strong when you are weak’, said Chinese strategist Sun Tzu (496 BC). Has the Chief of Defence Services (CDS) General Bipin Rawat taken the saying too seriously?

If the US highest military officer, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee were to issue a military threat to China on the South China Sea, an appropriate response from the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) would be assured. When India’s Chief of Defence Staff, General Bipin Rawat recently said that the military option was on the table if IndiaChina talks on Ladakh fail, there was deafening silence from the PLA.

The reason was simple: Discerning observers of new age technologies understood that either General Rawat was grandstanding, or was simply out of his depth on the changed character of warfare.

The huge gap between the technologies and the concept of operations or the art of war-fighting between the PLA and the Indian military could perhaps be explained by the analogy of the 1991 Gulf War. The war lasted 43 days of which the ground war was a mere 100 hours, essentially a mopping up operation. The Iraqi army’s elite Republican Guards battle-hardened in the decade long war with the neighbouring Iran were beaten by the US technology without a fight. 

The world, especially the PLA, was dumbstruck by the US’ new concept of warfare pivoted on stealth, guided munitions, stand-off ranges, and above all battle network centricity (real time connectivity between sensor, shooters and command post).

The PLA was quick to understand that it did not have the technology, scientific-industrial infrastructure, and finances to match the US military’s technological superiority. But it could develop ‘systems destruction warfare’ — capability to cripple US battle network’s command, control, communication, and intelligence systems — to deny or delay information to the enemy which is crucial for timely decision-making in war.

This was sought to be done by both non-kinetic and kinetic means, namely, by focussing on cyber and electronic warfare, and missiles (ballistic and cruise) capabilities. By early 2000, the PLA’s ‘assassin’s mace’ capabilities meant to incapacitate the enemy, suddenly and totally, by denying him information, instead of fighting him directly, had caught the US military’s attention.

A bigger shock awaited the US military when by 2012, it realised that the PLA had become a peer competitor in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and eleven new age disruptive technologies poised to reshape warfare and geopolitics while ushering in the fourth industrial revolution for prosperity.

These technologies are microelectronics, cyber, 5G wireless communications, space, hypersonic, directed energy weapons, autonomy, network communications, missile defence, quantum technologies, and nuclear triad. In certain technologies like 5G, AI and quantum, China was suspected to be ahead of the US.

This resulted in the US announcing its Third Offset strategy in 2014 to focus on robotics, autonomy and human-machine fusion. The Third Offset strategy, meant to meet China’s challenge, was testimony to the PLA’s technology driven upward trajectory for war-fighting.

Unfortunately, Indian military leaders fixated on Pakistan and counter-terror operations for 30 years since 1990 had completely missed the burgeoning challenges on the Line of Actual Control (LAC) with the PLA.

This is especially true for General Rawat who was deep selected for his stated expertise in counter terror operations to become the army chief in December 2016. Since the PLA is not the Pakistan military, it should have been obvious that a new template for warfare would be needed to check China. Surely, the PLA will not fight to Indian Army’s strength which is battle-hardened manpower. It would instead fight to its own strength: technology. When the CDS threatened China, he betrayed ignorance of PLA’s grown war-fighting capabilities. It was also lost on him and most analysts that the 2017 Doklam and the Ladakh crisis are as dissimilar as chalk and cheese.

Assuming that General Rawat is reckless and decides to execute his manpower-centric plan by opening up a new front on the 3,488km long LAC to put pressure on the PLA to evict occupied territory in eastern Ladakh; once the first shot is fired from the Indian side, an instant response from the PLA with four likely simultaneous actions based on its capabilities is certain.

One, there could be a massive cyber offensive culminating in cyberwar involving the whole-of-nation way beyond the designated battlespace. Since Chinese companies are embedded in India’s telecommunications, power, information and communications, and defence grids, it is anyone’s guess what a cyberwar (the world has never seen this) in virtual battlespace would do. There would be panic, fear, and frenzy in commercial and financial sectors with the government at its wit’s end.

Two, the PLA would unleash its ‘systems destruction’ strategy by its two organisations which report directly to the Central Military Commission, China’s highest military policy making body. These are the Strategic Support Force comprising cyber, space, electronic and psychological capabilities, and the Rocket Force which has under it all ballistic, cruise and hypersonic missiles.

Given this, India’s space satellites would be hit by cyber malware, PLA’s sub-orbital kill satellites and anti-satellite capabilities. Also hit would be command centres, various field headquarters and airfields to name a few critical information nodes. The overall PLA objective would be to deny information to Indian military for timely decision-making. This would result in the PLA getting ahead on the decision-making loop, allowing it faster responses. Importantly, the PLA has fielded AI technology enabler into its warfare. This would affect all aspects of war-fighting—quicker and better Intelligence, Reconnaissance and Surveillance (ISR), early decision-making and accurate and standoff responses.

Two examples would help show the uses of AI, which is still in early stages of development, in war. The PLA is known to have AI in its weapons including cruise missiles. This means that cruise missile would be autonomous and intelligent, capable of identifying targets and destroying them without help from ground controller.

Moreover, the PLA has demonstrated capability of one ground station controlling large numbers of drones or unmanned aerial vehicles. It is certain that Indian military’s trained manpower pitted against technology would not achieve its objective of evicting the PLA from occupied territories. This is what makes General Rawat’s warning unreal.

 
 

‘Dear girlies, thank you for…’: What Meg…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

Meghan Markle's handwritten note to American Airlines flight attendants, expressing gratitude for their hospitality, has surfaced on social media, showcasing her personal touch. This commercial flight appearance contrasts with past...

Read more

Will Donald Trump’s ‘big beautiful bill’…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

President Trump's One Big Beautiful Bill Act faces significant hurdles in the Senate after a narrow House passage. Republican Senators like Ron Johnson and Rand Paul express concerns over the...

Read more

Israel's US ambassador called home over …

25-05-2025

Sample Image

Israel's ambassador to Washington is being summoned home on the instructions of a government disciplinary body to discuss comments he made in a podcast interview, the foreign ministry said Sunday...

Read more

Who is Derek Chauvin? The cop who murder…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

Five years after George Floyd's murder by Derek Chauvin, the world remembers the tragic event that sparked global protests against systemic racism. Chauvin's conviction on all charges brought a mix...

Read more

Art project or UFO? Scientists torn over…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

A mysterious metallic sphere discovered in Colombia has sparked debate, with some speculating about extraterrestrial origins due to its seamless construction. Researchers are studying the object, while others suggest it...

Read more

France's Macron arrives in Vietnam for S…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

Emmanuel Macron's Southeast Asia tour aims to position France as a reliable alternative to the US and China, emphasizing respect for Asian sovereignty. He will promote French expertise in civil...

Read more

Uganda 'suspends' military cooperation w…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

Uganda has suspended military cooperation with Germany, alleging that the German ambassador, Mathias Schauer, is involved in subversive activities against the Ugandan government. This escalation follows accusations that some European...

Read more

Is media backing off criticism of US gov…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

ABC executives, including Disney's CEO, have reportedly urged the hosts of 'The View' to tone down their anti-Trump rhetoric and broaden the show's content. However, the hosts, including Ana Navarro...

Read more

Thousands rally in Warsaw for Polish pre…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

Tens of thousands of people rallied in central Warsaw on Sunday in rival demonstrations for the two candidates in Poland's presidential election on June 1. Organisers estimated there were around...

Read more

South Africa's Malema vows to keep chant…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

South Africa's firebrand opposition leader on Saturday vowed to keep using controversial chants that featured in a contentious White House meeting between the US and South African presidents. Speaking at...

Read more

The US military spent $6 billion in the …

25-05-2025

Sample Image

Faced with enlistment shortfalls, the US military spent over $6 billion on recruitment and retention incentives in the last three years. The Navy significantly outspent other branches, particularly on retention...

Read more

Mediation or informal diplomacy? Decodin…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

Following the Pahalgam terror attack and India's 'Operation Sindoor,' a dispute arose over whether a US-brokered ceasefire occurred between India and Pakistan. While Trump claimed US mediation, India asserted its...

Read more

Air raid sirens in Jerusalem as army say…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

The Israeli army intercepted a missile launched from Yemen on Sunday, triggering air raid sirens in Jerusalem. This attack, claimed by Yemen's Huthis, targeted Ben Gurion airport near Tel Aviv...

Read more

Five years of Black Lives Matter: 3 ways…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

As the fifth anniversary of Floyd’s death approaches, here are three ways the MAGA movement has flipped the narrative — turning a symbol of police brutality into an emblem of...

Read more

‘They lost Annabelle?’ Internet meltdown…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

The infamous Annabelle doll recently sparked internet frenzy after rumors spread about its disappearance during a paranormal tour in the US. This occurred shortly after a fire at a Louisiana...

Read more

'Upgrade nukes, big China's support': Wh…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

A US intelligence report reveals Pakistan's military priorities, emphasizing nuclear modernization and addressing cross-border tensions with regional neighbors. China remains Pakistan's primary defense partner, providing economic and military support, while...

Read more

Vietnam police detain man over damage to…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

Vietnamese police have detained a man who broke into a history exhibit and damaged an antique throne considered to be one of the nation's most precious artefacts, conservation officials said...

Read more

Russia unleashes largest air onslaught o…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

Russia launched its most extensive aerial assault on Ukraine since the war's onset, targeting over 30 cities and villages with missiles and drones, resulting in casualties and widespread damage. The...

Read more

UK renationalises first train operator u…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

A private train operator servicing parts of southern England, including London, on Sunday became the first to be returned to public ownership under a government plan to renationalise Britain's much-maligned...

Read more

Fire cuts power to 45,000 in French Rivi…

25-05-2025

Sample Image

French Riviera authorities said Sunday they are boosting security around electricity grid sites after an overnight fire in a substation that cut power to 45,000 people, and a massive blackout...

Read more